STATE MECHANISM OF REGULATING THE DIGITAL SPACE
https://doi.org/10.52425/25187252_2025_38_37
Abstract
This article is devoted to the legal understanding of the role of the state in the context of contemporary digital transformation. Particular attention is paid to institutional and regulatory mechanisms through which the state exercises its regulatory functions and participates in the operation of the digital environment. The article analyses relevant initiatives, including the draft Law of the Republic of Kazakhstan “On Artificial Intelligence” (2025), as well as selected foreign approaches implemented within the European Union and the United States. Special focus is given to the legal status of the state in the digital space and the challenges of ensuring the protection of individual digital rights.
Two main approaches to the implementation of the digital transformation of the public administration system are analyzed, “the pros” and “cons” of the approaches under consideration are identified.
The main issues that should be focused on by civil society and government agencies have been identified. These include: the likelihood of algorithmic bias that will lead to AI making wrong decisions; digital inequality among various segments of the population of Kazakhstan; vulnerability of government digital systems in cases of cyber attacks on government information resources; fragmentation of digital solutions.
Also a serious problem is the lack of an appropriate regulatory framework to protect the digital rights of individuals, ensure responsible behavior in the digital environment, and regulate the mechanisms of state and public control over the functioning and development of artificial intelligence systems. The authors of the article propose ways to solve the above-mentioned problems of regulating the digital space.
Keywords
About the Authors
A. A. MukashevaKazakhstan
Mukasheva Anor Abaikhankyzy – Professor of the School of Law and Public Administration at Narxoz University, Doctor of Law, Associate Professor.
Almaty
E. F. Nigmatullina
Russian Federation
Nigmatullina Elmira Faatovna – Associate Professor of the Department of Environmental, Labor Law and Civil Procedure at Kazan (Volga Region) Federal University, Doctor of Law, Associate Professor.
Kazan
References
1. Amangel'dy, A.A. Vnedrenie norm o cifrovyh tehnologijah v zakonodatel'stvo Respubliki Kazahstan / A.A. Amangel'dy // Vestnik Instituta zakonodatel'stva i pravovoj informacii RK. – 2021. – № 3 (66). – S. 34-43.
2. Daulieva, G. Gosudarstvennoe upravlenie cifrovoj jekonomikoj v Respublike Kazahstan / G. Daulieva, M. Islamoglu, A. Eralieva // Kazahstan-Spektr. – 2021. – № 100 (4) [Electronic resource] – Access mode: https://journal-ks.kisi.kz/index.php/ks/article/view/85 (Access date: 12.11.2025).
3. Dujsebaeva, M. Cifrovaja transformacija gosudarstvennogo upravlenija reforma / M. Dujsebaeva // Voprosy dokumentooborota. – 2021. – № 6. – S. 48-55.
4. Dujsen, G.M. Formirovanie cifrovogo prostranstva Kazahstana i stran Central'noj Azii v uslovijah industrial'noj revoljucii / G.M. Dujsen, D.A. Ajtzhanova // Jekonomika. – 2018. – № 4 (92). – S. 77-90.
5. Idrysheva, S.K. O Cifrovom kodekse Kazahstana /s.K. Idrysheva // Pravo i gosudarstvo. – 2022. – № 3 (96). – S. 72-87.
6. Sarybaev, M. Cifrovaja transformacija stran Central'noaziatskogo regiona: perspektivy sfery gosudarstvennogo upravlenija Kazahstana / M. Sarybaev, E. Chukubaev, A. Maltabarov // KazahstanSpektr. – 2022. – № 4 (104). – S. 83-101.
7. Mukanov, A. The main indicators of the state program «Digital Kazakhstan» // Current Issues and Prospects for The Development of Scientific Research: Proceedings of the 7th International Scientific and Practical Conference (April 19-20, 2023). – Orléans, France, 2023. – Pp. 25-38.
8. Lamzin, R.M. Transformacija sistemy publichnogo upravlenija v uslovijah cifrovizacii: avtoref. dis. … kand. jekon. nauk / R.M. Lamzin. – Kursk, 2024. – 24 s.
9. Mushtakov, V.E. Prava cheloveka v uslovijah cifrovizacii obshhestva: konstitucionno-pravovoe issledovanie: dis. … kand. jurid. nauk / V.E. Mushtakov. – Omsk, 2024. – 238 s.
10. Barocas, S. Big Data's Disparate Impact /s. Barocas, A. Selbst // California Law Review. – 2016. – № 671. – Pp. 671-732.
11. Burlacu, S. Digital Public Administration for Sustainable Development /s. Burlacu, M. Loredana, A. Diaconu // European Journal of Sustainable Development. – 2021. – № 10 (4). – Pp. 33-40.
12. Dunleavy, P. New Public Management Is Dead – Long Live Digital-Era Governance / P. Dunleavy, H. Margetts, S. Bastow, J. Tinkler // Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory. – 2006. – № 16 (3). – Pp. 467-494.
13. Lyakhova, N.I. Gis technology role and place in russian economy digitalization / N.I. Lyakhova // Independent Journal of Management & Production (IJM&P). – 2022. – Pp. 503-513.
14. Rastoropov, S.V. Global Challenges and Prospects of the Modern Economic Development. On legal policy and legal practice relations in the ERA of digitalization /s.V. Rastoropov, A.P. Korobova, D.A. Karev // European Proceedings of Social and Behavioural Sciences. – 2020. – Pp. 1151-1155.
15. Rezaul, K. The State Economical Regulation Practice Modernization in Terms of Business Digitalization / K. Rezaul, D. Ushakov // In book: Strategic and Pragmatic E-Business. – Pp. 352-376.
16. Sidorenko, E.L. Transformation of Law in the Context of Digitalization: Defining the correct priorities / E.L. Sidorenko, P. von Arx // Digital Law Journal. – 2020. – № 1 (1). – Pp. 24-38.
Review
For citations:
Mukasheva A.A., Nigmatullina E.F. STATE MECHANISM OF REGULATING THE DIGITAL SPACE. Bulletin of the Law Enforcement Academy. 2025;(4 (38)):37-45. https://doi.org/10.52425/25187252_2025_38_37
JATS XML

