CONDITIONS OF DETENTION AND LEGAL MECHANISMS AGAINST TORTURE: KAZAKHSTAN AND INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE
Abstract
This article examines conditions of detention as an integral element of ensuring human rights, emphasizing the need for them to comply with international legal standards. The work presents a comprehensive analysis of violations in the penitentiary system of Kazakhstan, including the use of torture, cruel or degrading treatment, and identifies shortcomings in legal mechanisms for protection and the level of responsibility for unlawful actions. The following are proposed as specific measures to prevent torture: mandatory participation of a lawyer at the early stages of pre-trial proceedings, audio and video recording of interrogations, increased responsibility for torture and expansion of procedural guarantees.
The authors of the study emphasize the importance of improving legal norms, noting the need to create an independent monitoring institution and implement effective legal protection mechanisms. These measures play an important role in preventing violations and protecting the rights of detainees.
About the Authors
Zh. K. KarazhanovaKazakhstan
Karazhanova Zhanat Kokenovna – Senior Lecturer of the Department of Criminal Law Disciplines
Astana
A. S. Bekten
Kazakhstan
Bekten Aybolat Samatuly – Associate Professor of the Department of Prosecutorial Supervision at the Institute of Professional Training
Kosshy
References
1. Shushikova, G.K. Voprosy protivodejstvija pytkam v Kazahstane / G.K. Shushikova, E.S. Kemali, M.G. Azhibaev // Құқyқ қorғau organdary akademijasynyң Zharshysy. – 2020. – № 3 (17). – S. 46-52.
2. M. André (Ontario Ombudsman) Investigation into the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services’ response to allegations of excessive use of force against inmates. – 2013 [Jelektrondyқ resurs] – Ajnalys rezhimі: https://www.ombudsman.on.ca/resources/reports-and-casesummaries/reports-on-investigations/2013/the-code (zhүgіngen kүnі: 17.07.2025).
3. Mamyrbaev, R.N. Obzor mezhdunarodnogo opyta, analiz nacional'nogo zakonodatel'stva i pravoprimenitel'noj praktiki po voprosam preduprezhdenija pytok i drugih form zhestokogo obrashhenija i nakazanija // Usilenie nacional'nyh pravozashhitnyh mehanizmov Kazahstana. – Astana, 2024. – 198 s.
4. Urs Kindhäuser, H.C. Strafprozessrecht, Aufl / H.C. Urs Kindhäuser, H. Schumann Nomos Kay. – Berlin: 2023. – 460 p.
5. Allbon, E. Elliott and quinn’s. Еnglish legal system / E. Allbon, S.K. Dua. – 2020. – 400 p.
6. Toshtemirova, R.F. Sledstvennaja vlast' v zarubezhnom ugolovnom processe / R.F. Toshtemirova // Vestnik Nizhegorodskoj akademii MVD Rossii. – 2020. – № 4 (52). – S. 150-154.
7. Kalinovskij, K.B. Ugolovnyj process sovremennyh zarubezhnyh gosudarstv: uchebnoe posobie / K.B. Kalinovskij. – Petrozavodsk: Izd-vo PetrGU, 2000. – 48 s.
Review
For citations:
Karazhanova Zh.K., Bekten A.S. CONDITIONS OF DETENTION AND LEGAL MECHANISMS AGAINST TORTURE: KAZAKHSTAN AND INTERNATIONAL EXPERIENCE. Bulletin of the Law Enforcement Academy. 2025;(3 (37)):106-115. (In Kazakh)
JATS XML

